• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Mama Cimino's Pizza: The Best Chicago Tavern Style Pizza in Lake Geneva

Mama Cimino's Pizza, located in Lake Geneva, WI, is a beloved family-friendly Italian restaurant known for its cozy atmosphere and exceptional customer service. Reviewers consistently rave about the rich flavors of their Chicago tavern-style pizzas, loaded with generous toppings and a delectable sauce. The restaurant stays open late, making it a perfect late-night stop, with patrons praising the prompt and friendly staff. Beyond pizza, the menu offers delightful options like cheesy bread and steak tacos, all at reasonable prices. Each visit promises a warm experience that leaves guests eager to return for another serving of their culinary delights.

Mama Cimino's Pizza at a glance

  • Address 131-1 N Wells St, Lake Geneva, WI 53147, United States
  • Phone +1 262-348-9077
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Family restaurant , Italian restaurant , Meal delivery , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Mama Cimino's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Xavier Galvan
5

Review pictures are deceiving. Much cozier and pleasant in person, family friendly. We came on a fall Friday night and had our choice of seating with Prompt service and greetings by all. Great cimino style, Chicago tavern style pizza. Pizza was good, hit the spot.

tal a
5

We arri We arrived at the pizzeria late at night, around midnight. The girl who took our order was patient, kind, and very friendly. We waited in the car and she brought the order out to us. The pasta came with a salad, and everything was nicely packed, clean, and beautifully arranged. The service was excellent, the food was delicious, and the prices were very reasonable. Highly recommended!

Julie Gramse
5

We find this to be the BEST Pizza in the area, Delicious, beautiful pizzas with generous toppings on everything we've ever ordered. We've had the best experiences every single time we've ordered. I'm guessing about 18-2 times a year since we found it several years ago. Thank you to the owners and workers who do such an amazing job!

YANA STERLING
5

Family friendly Italian restaurant. Usually this is our after the bar stop bc they stay open very late. They are always accommodating and have excellent customer service. Hands down best waitress and owner! Flavors on the pizza are amazing and ooooh the cheesy bread and that succulent sauce! They recently added so much to their menu. We also tried the steak taco and it was so good! Highly recommend! Fair prices, free parking.

Yazari Gutierrez
5

If you're looking for great food and great service, come eat here! Our server, Stacy, was so welcoming and had us laughing the whole time we were there. The wings and pizza were great! We will definitely be returning. :)

Jess Sutton
5

Nice little pizza joint. Staff is friendly and helpful. Place isn’t fancy. Prices were good. Got the Pepperoni Rolls and they were great. Got 14 inch Ciminos Crust(thin) with Sausage/Black Olives. Very Tasty and thought sausage was excellent. Will go back.

Kate P
5

I just called to order Pizza for a Wedding at the Riviera in a month from today and the man answering the phone was so sweet! They do late night delivery and he is willing to hold on to our order for the next 4 weeks. We called other pizza places in town and they do not do late night delivery so I am very thankful for this pizza place!

Victoria Walsh
5

Visiting lake Geneva on vacation, most places close the kitchen about 9 on a Thursday but thank goodness for mama ciminos! Everyone was very welcoming an our server “farmer” was very friendly, knowledgeable and proud of this establishment, that did not disappoint! Appetizers wings were HUGE and perfectly crispy, pizza was delicious and desserts are mouth watering. Worth a visit. -from NC

Location

  • Mama Cimino's Pizza
    Mama Cimino's Pizza
    131-1 N Wells St, Lake Geneva, WI 53147, United States Hotline: +1 262-348-9077

Welcome to the heart of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, where "Mama Cimino's Pizza" has become a beloved staple for locals and visitors alike. Nestled at 131-1 N Wells St, this family-friendly Italian eatery offers a cozy atmosphere that welcomes everyone—from families enjoying a night out to late-night diners in need of a delicious bite after the bars. As soon as you walk in, the warm, inviting decor and the friendly faces of the staff will make you feel right at home.

What sets Mama Cimino's apart is not just the ambiance, but the incredible food. While the restaurant showcases a variety of Italian delights, their specialty lies in their Chicago tavern-style pizza. Thick, crispy crusts adorned with generous toppings make each slice a delightful experience. As one satisfied customer, Julie Gramse, put it, this is the “BEST pizza in the area,” and her loyal patronage over the years speaks volumes.

But there's more to Mama Cimino's than just pizza. Their menu has recently expanded, inviting guests to explore new offerings such as juicy steak tacos, all while maintaining the fantastic flavors that have won over the hearts of many. The cheesy bread and succulent sauces deserve a special mention, drawing rave reviews from diners like YANA STERLING, who highlighted the restaurant's excellent customer service alongside sumptuous meals.

Late-night visits also yield memorable experiences, where diners are treated with patience and care, as noted by customer tal a. From beautifully arranged dishes to excellent packing, Mama Cimino's ensures that every order is a reflection of their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.

In essence, Mama Cimino's Pizza is more than just a place to grab a meal; it’s a community hub that emphasizes delicious food, heartfelt service, and an inviting atmosphere. Whether you're stopping by for a slice with friends, enjoying a cozy dinner with family, or indulging in a late-night treat, Mama Cimino's promises an unforgettable experience every time. So gather your loved ones and head over to this Lake Geneva gem—you won't regret it!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards